Why Many Golfers Still View The World Handicap System Negatively

It's been five years since the World Handicap System (WHS) was introduced in England, Scotland, Wales and the island of Ireland - bringing in a new era that supplanted the structure that golfers had been used to for generations.

There have been small tweaks along the way since then, but the system that was engineered to ensure consistency across the globe and to simplify the handicapping process is undeniably here to stay.

But are golfers themselves happy about that? It's fair to say that the reaction to the WHS has been mixed, but that's likely to be said of anything new.

Featured Content

However, there are still a significant number of dissenting voices as we reach the half-decade point of its existence. 

(Image Credit: Kevin Diss Photography)

Recently surveying 2,500 golfers, we received a lot of feedback on the WHS, which was generally negative in tone with several issues being frequently mentioned.

People are often more vocal with complaints than praise, so this perspective is by no means universal, but it's clear that many golfers still haven't accepted and fully embraced the World Handicap System.

Why Do Golfers Still View The World Handicap System Negatively?

We received a deluge of comments on the WHS, but there were recurring themes that repeatedly appeared in responses.

• Perceived Unfairness

Many of the golfers who responded to our survey expressed their dissatisfaction with the WHS, with some even going as far as describing it as unfair and a "cheaters charter."

There were concerns that the WHS allowed non-members to maintain active handicaps without participating in club competitions, which was seen as undermining the integrity of the handicap system.

• Impact on Club Membership

Indeed, one of the most notable changes that the WHS ushered in was that it allows golfers to maintain handicaps without being a member of a golf club, which some believe may contribute to a decline in membership numbers, as it takes away a key incentive of joining a club and paying membership fees.

However, the evidence that we've seen doesn't support that takeaway as membership numbers remain strong at a majority of clubs - and are even flourishing at some - but it could be something to watch into the future as more golfers seek to embrace flexibility with how they interact with the game.

• Complexity & Confusion

Despite the belief that it would make for a simpler, more straightforward handicap system, many of the golfers who responded to us have found the WHS to be overly complicated and confusing, with various definitions (e.g., Course Handicap, Playing Handicap) adding to the complexity.

However, recent changes that have been launched in Ireland (with further expansion to come in 2026) regarding the calculation of Playing Handicaps should alleviate many of those concerns.

• Lack of Trust in Non-Members' Handicaps

The integrity of competitions is fundamental but some of the members who responded to us described their lack of trust in the handicaps of non-members. There was a general feeling that the handicaps of non-members were not subject to the same level of scrutiny as those of golfers who are members of golf clubs. This was seen as a potential source of unfairness in competitions.

• Negative Impact on Competitions

Related to that point, club members reported to us that they viewed the WHS as having a negative impact on their club competitions, making them less enjoyable or meaningful, with comments also addressing concerns that there had been an increase in disputes and disagreements among members.

The WHS remains divisive, and the comments we received were largely critical, especially from those who are members of golf clubs.

It's likely that as time progresses and the World Handicap System becomes more deeply embedded and normalised, some of these complaints will dissipate, but for now, there is no doubt that the WHS is viewed deeply negatively by a significant proportion of the golfing population. 

Do any of these issues resonate with you - and how do you view the World Handicap System five years on?

Related Content

Is The World Handicap System Really a Cheat's Charter?

Changes to The World Handicap System That Could Affect You

Benefits of World Handicap System Now Obvious

The World Handicap System Continues to Cause Controversy

What The World Handicap System Gets Right