Can this huge golf club membership increase be justified?

Share

Whether it be when filling your trolley at the supermarket, putting petrol into your car, or managing your energy bills, we've pretty much all become accustomed to the reality that prices are rising and everything seems to be costing more than it did just a few years ago.

Therefore, it stands to reason that your golf club membership isn't immune to this inflationary trend, either, with golfers now used to the fact that they are spending more on their annual fees than they did previously.

Although club membership broadly remains popular and continues to the foundational bedrock of the sport, particularly in traditional heartlands like the UK, that doesn't mean prospective members and even existing ones aren't beginning to question whether they are still getting value for that they are paying.

Are golfers still getting value from their club memberships?

Looking at this issue recently on Golfshake, we wrote: "Let's say you're paying £1,000 for a membership. If you're playing 50 times a year, that's £20 per round. Naturally, if you can average a couple of rounds each week across the season, the value of that fee becomes tremendous.

"However, let's say you only get out there once a week during the peak months, encompassing maybe 20 rounds a year, that subscription will be broken down to £50 per round, which is simply unjustifiable for many people, where better value could be found in just paying as you play."

Most golfers will recognise the fact that outgoings for clubs themselves are going up, whether it be the cost of energy, fuel, materials, and the expense of maintaining sufficient staffing levels to provide the product and service that both members and visitors expect from a good golf club.

But when does an increase simply become too much?

Can a 60% price increase be justified?

Arbroath Golf Links

Members of the acclaimed Arbroath Golf Links in Scotland might be asking themselves that question as it has been revealed that the cost of a full adult membership will go up by 60% by 2029.

Speaking to The Courier, Craig Knowles, director of the venue, has explained why this change is necessary to allow them to operate on a more sustainable level, potentially creating the opportunity to expand staffing numbers in key positions.

"We are quite a small team," Craig said. "There are only three full-time greenkeepers, which is how many were employed when I started in 2018, so it seems to have always been the case.

"It is not enough and it doesn’t allow us to do everything we would like to. But there just isn’t the budget to employ any more people.

"We are fortunate to have some really good volunteers that come and help on the course. Some of them have been members for a while and some of them have only joined the club in the last two years."

Craig's management role accompanies his more established position as Head PGA Professional, demonstrating that multiple responsibilities are taken on by the same people as the facility simply cannot afford to have individual roles.

This is why costs are going up for everyone

Maintaining a golf course is a costly endeavour, one that requires raw materials and manpower, which needs to be paid for somehow, as Craig described when speaking to The Courier.

"Our biggest costs are staffing, course upkeep and machinery," he added.

"We’re unfortunately not in the position where we can buy the machines we need to maintain the course outright. We just don’t have that type of capital lying about.

"So in general, everything we have is leased.

"And things like sand, seed, fertiliser, they have all massively increased in cost in the last few years.

"I would say since Covid, the cost of running a golf course has more than doubled.

"Some of the information we’ve put out to members in the last week, with our membership plan, to try and push the amount of capital we have to spend on the golf course.

"Everything that comes into the club, gets reinvested back on to the course.

"Although there is a board of directors, these positions are all voluntary.

"None of them are paid.

"And if we keep the fees at the level they are now, then unfortunately all that is going to happen is we would be unable to even maintain our course. It is only going to decline."

Sometimes you have to pay more to maintain quality

Arbroath

Now, a 60% rise over three seasons might - on the face of it - appear to be shocking. But let's place into context the costs involved.

This year, a full adult membership was priced at £470, which will rise to £600 in 2027, £675 in 2028, and £750 in 2029.

Across this period, seniors will go up from £445 to £750, with an age 18-21 membership rising from £225 to £450, an age 22-30 membership of £340 going up to £650, and an under 18 junior just over doubling from £55 to £115.

Those concessionary increases do feel step, but you also have to consider what is being paid for.

Craig added: "Our green fees are £140, but we offer different rates including the James Braid rate, which means members of other James Braid clubs get 50% off that."

The links - originally laid out by Old Tom Morris in the 1870s - was revamped in 1931 by Braid.

What this means is that members will pay £600 in 2027, which is just over four times the price of the regular, peak season green fee for one round. 

If you're someone who ticks off dozens of rounds each season, that expense, to have regular access to what is a positively regarded and coveted links, doesn't seem so bad.

This is a golf course you want to play regularly

Highly Recommended on Golfshake, here are a couple of reviews that have been submitted this past season.

One golfer said: "A superb links course. We were able to get in an impressive 36 holes when we came up from England. We had a great fairly calm day but I can imagine that once that wind gets up then it is a completely different beast. Excellent catering facilities and many thanks to the club pro for making it an easy day for us. Deffo one to recommend."

Another reported: "Played here now a few times, however this was the first time that I played it in strong winds. Was a great test and love this course. Played it with my son and this was his first time playing links so it is a great entry level for him as it's a test but relatively forgiving as well with a few open fairways."

Arbroath sounds like the sort of place that you would dearly love to be a member of.

That said, it's not for us to judge those who think these price increases are too high, that is an individual perspective and an argument that can be solidly made when looking at the raw numbers, but the open communication that has been displayed by the management is to be applauded, while even the 2029 membership fee, though dramatically higher than it is now, is still far lower than other prestigious courses in this part of Scotland.

Wherever you are located, if golfers want their courses to remain sustainable and to deliver the quality they wish for, more of us will have to dig a little deeper into our pockets as clubs attempt to successfully navigate through the economy that we're all being challenged by.

About the author

Kieran Clark is the Digital Editor of Golfshake. He oversees editorial content, community engagement, forums, and social media channels. A lifelong golfer from the Isle of Bute in Scotland who has now lived in St Andrews for a decade, he began playing at the age of five and maintains a passion for exploring courses, with a particular affection for historic layouts. Kieran regularly contributes in-depth opinion pieces and features, drawing on his enthusiasm for the game and its culture.

KC
Scroll to top