Are these the toughest holes that golfers can ever play?

Share

Just like a good book or television series, the best golf courses consist of memorable chapters and episodes that, for us, come in the form of individual holes that complete an experience worth reliving.

Some of these holes will be spectacularly scenic, they might be tantalisingly strategic, boast iconic imagery or embrace the surrounding landscape naturally. 

But there are others that are just plain tough - and that is what you'll remember most about them.

The holes that combine difficulty with several of the other factors we mentioned above are the ones that truly deserve legendary status.

What is the toughest golf hole you have played? That was a question we presented to the Golfshake Community on Facebook, attracting hundreds of responses, but there were several standouts that were repeatedly mentioned to such an extent that they merit further attention. 

It's time for you to meet some of the hardest holes in anywhere in the game, according to other golfers.

Anstruther Golf Club, 5th

Known as The Rockies, this is a par 3 that is building up its own legend. Tucked away on the East Neuk of Fife, just down the road from St Andrews, you will come across the fishing town of Anstruther, which is home to a nine-hole course that is famed for one hole in particular.

Measuring up to 245 yards, you have to somehow navigate a range of obstacles that include a steep cliff, rocky outcrops, and the imposing waters of the Firth of Forth. Yikes!

One golfer responded to us by saying: "At 240 yds from the back, with the beach close and a cliff to the right, it is best played without a card! An intimidating prospect."

We can't argue with that. 

St Enodoc Golf Club (Church Course), 10th

St Enodoc

(Image Credit: Kevin Murray Photography)

A real jewel of Cornwall, the 10th hole of the classic James Braid-designed Church Course of St Enodoc was a popular choice in the minds of golfers.

Measuring between 449 and 457 yards, this is a fearsome par 4 that presents a water hazard all the way down the left and dunes on the right. It might also be impacted by the coastal winds that you can regularly anticipate when visiting this beautiful part of the country.

This golfer said: "The 10th at St Enodoc. Ridiculous par 4. Completely unreachable brute of a hole!"

It sounds like that hole ticks a few boxes!

The Old Course at St Andrews Links, 17th

Road Hole

(Image Credit: Kevin Murray Photography)

You just knew that the famous Road Hole would be featured here. Undeniably one of the most iconic holes in the game, it has terrorised golfers for centuries, partly because it was originally engineered to be a par 5. 

Making a four here is quite an achievement. Especially when you have that fierce tee shot over the old railway sheds that hug the corner of the Old Course Hotel, but really it's the second shot, the approach towards the green, that is most perilous as you're faced with a uniquely angled surface that is protected by the Road bunker to the front and the road itself (which is in play) beyond at the back.

It will surely once again have a say in who lifts the Claret Jug at St Andrews next July.

Carnoustie Golf Links (Championship Course), 16th

Carnoustie

(Image Credit: Kevin Murray Photography)

Golf fans were thrilled to see that Carnoustie will once again stage the Open in 2029. It's one of the sport's greatest tests, a challenging design that always identifies a champion who held both their nerve and game together.

Ultimately, you could have picked any of the closing stretch here, but the one that stood out was the lengthy par 3 16th, which Tom Watson notably did not par once on his way to winning the championship in 1975. 

That says it all.

You could easily have included the 17th or (especially) the dramatic 18th of the Championship Course, but I would also point out that the 15th is easily one of the most brutally difficult holes that I have ever played.

Carnoustie's officially tough. Who knew?!

Tralee Golf Club, 12th

Rated as the stroke index one hole at Tralee, the 12th (called Braken) is a par 4 that measures somewhere in the region of 460 yards, which demands that you hit a long, accurate drive, avoiding the dunes that frame the fairway, before playing up towards an elevated green in the distance.

Throw in a sea breeze and you have quite the golfing examination ahead of you.

Likewise, the par 5 11th, named Palmer's Peak, is steeply uphill, which shocked one golfer, who said: "I took four good hits to get there and the best golfer in our group took driver and two three woods to get close."

Royal Dornoch Golf Club (Championship Course), 14th

One of the most special layouts in the game, Royal Dornoch is a treasure that merits its revered reputation, but one hole perhaps grabs more attention than others, and that is the 14th, known as Foxy.

Measuring about 445 yards, this is a par 4 that doesn't present any bunkers to catch you out. The obstacles here are a little different - but no less punishing.

You can't afford to be wayward as you progress up the snaking fairway that leads to a plateau green that sits across from you, making it exceptionally hard to hit from distance.

This golfer commented: "My caddie said he can go all year without seeing more then a couple GIRs."

Saunton Golf Club (East Course), 1st

Celebrated course architect Herbert Fowler was the man who laid out the East Course at Saunton Golf Club in North Devon. And starts to a round don't come much tougher than this - particularly if you play off the back tees where this becomes a par 4 reaching up to 470 yards in length.

One golfer responded: "Nobody should have to start a round on a 470yd par 4!"

But at Saunton, that's what you can face, and its placing right at the start is likely what takes it to another level altogether in terms of the raw challenge.

Those are just some of the tough holes that were mentioned often. There were dozens of others that we could have shone the spotlight on, but hopefully these create a little bit of debate and intrigue in your head.

Personally, when it comes to St Andrews, beyond the Road Hole, I don't think a combination comes much more treacherous than the 9th (a long par 3) and the 10th (a long par 4) both packed with danger on the New Course.

But that's without raising just how comically inept I am on the apparently straightforward 1st hole of the Old Course, which proves that, in some cases, difficulty is really all in the eye of the beholder...

About the author

Kieran Clark is the Digital Editor of Golfshake. He oversees editorial content, community engagement, forums, and social media channels. A lifelong golfer from the Isle of Bute in Scotland who has now lived in St Andrews for a decade, he began playing at the age of five and maintains a passion for exploring courses, with a particular affection for historic layouts. Kieran regularly contributes in-depth opinion pieces and features, drawing on his enthusiasm for the game and its culture.

KC
Scroll to top