Out of bounds question


Forum > Rules and Etiquette

Out of bounds question

John Flood


Handicap : 11.9

Posted : Wed 3rd Feb 2010 21:40

I have a question that I'm not sure about. In football the ball is deemed out if it crosses BUT comes back into play, i.e corners.

What applies in golf if your ball goes OOB in the air but lands in bounds OR lands OOB but finishes up in bounds??

I was thinking about this in relation to Dave Knatt's earlier post about playing the hole from a different way it was intended.

John.

Post reply

Darren Ramowski

[FORUM MODERATOR]
Handicap : 21

Reply : Wed 3rd Feb 2010 21:48

Think it's in play, think we also had a similar question to this and the ruling is kind of ambiguous but clear

Seem theory if you hit a tree out of bounds but it knocks it back in. 

Will search and get back to you

 

Post reply

Adrian Hope


Handicap : 9.9

Reply : Wed 3rd Feb 2010 21:49
Where it comes to rest is where it is, otherwise you could hit over an oob but end up on your own fairway on a dogleg and it would be called oob....but it isn't.....does that make sense ???
Last edit : Wed 3rd Feb 2010 21:49
Post reply

Adrian Hope


Handicap : 9.9

Reply : Wed 3rd Feb 2010 21:50
so if it comes to rest in bounds, then it is !!!
Post reply

Colin Stephens


Handicap : 19.6

Reply : Wed 3rd Feb 2010 21:52
exactly !!!
Post reply

John Pettitt


Handicap : 18

Reply : Wed 3rd Feb 2010 22:15
The ball is in play, John F, even if someone were to throw a bll back onto the course after going out of bounds, providing you did not ask for them to throw it back.
Post reply

Adrian Hope


Handicap : 9.9

Reply : Wed 3rd Feb 2010 22:18

I once saw Russ Abbot hit a ball over a wall onto a bus, it rolled down the stairs back over the wall onto the green to the edge of the hole, then the vibrations of a passing train made it fall in !

I bet he still didn't buy the drinks either (tight tw@t )

Post reply

John Flood


Handicap : 11.9

Reply : Wed 3rd Feb 2010 22:20

Cheers guys.

Now who fancies following me around next time I play & throwing my ball back into play for me??

Post reply

Patrick Bourke


Handicap : 11.1

Reply : Thu 4th Feb 2010 09:36
 Where the ball finishes up, I mean you could hit a ball that pitches in bounds but has a nasty kick and goes oob. Bad luck but it lies to rest oob.
Post reply

Dave Knatt


Handicap : 20.1

Reply : Sun 7th Feb 2010 10:38

John P - in the latest TG there's a specific question about a ball being thrown back into play by a bystander.

Their interpretation is that it's a penalty stroke if it comes to rest OB - if it's deflected back then that's ok.

So, if it's picked up and thrown back, it's a penalty, if your spectator hits it back without it coming to rest, then you're alright. 

Post reply

David Lythgoe

[FORUM MODERATOR]
Handicap : 2

Reply : Sun 7th Feb 2010 15:25

Dave,

The Rule is 'if it is known' that the ball was thrown back.

TheLyth

Post reply

Previous Post:yet another handicap question    |    Next Post: Great review of Merrist Wood Golf Club - played si ...

Post reply :

 Only registered logged in users can post new topics.

Click here to register for free.

Golfshake Features

 

 




Bookmark this page:


Delicious Digg StumbleUpon Facebook reddit