Golf forum



Forum > Rules and Etiquette
Is this illegal?
Tim Hawkins



Handicap : 21.5

Location :

Posts :
Posted : Wed 6th Aug 2008 13:02

Had a game with my brother the other day and he has suffered from the same swing faults as me for years, he tends to fall back when hitting iron shots induced a slice.  He then showed me a trick which helped him to stop doing it and I was wondering if it was legal to do this in a game.  Basically he put a spare ball down on the tee and stood on it with his right heel - I tried it and the slice magically disappeared!  He doesn't need to do it anymore but it worked for me - but is it legal to do it?


David Marshall



Handicap : 9.3

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 13:07

In a word......

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

&nbs
p;

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

&n
bsp;

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

&nbs
p;

 

NO

 

 

 

 

 

Last edit : Wed 6th Aug 2008 13:07

Tim Hawkins



Handicap : 21.5

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 14:10

No, it's illegal or no, it isn't?  If it's illegal, what rule is it breaking?  If I took my shoe off and put half a ball in it would this be the same?

Apart from the limp of course....

Last edit : Wed 6th Aug 2008 14:11

Wayne Santorini



Handicap : 15.4

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 14:18

at least it would match the lump on your back

David Marshall



Handicap : 9.3

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 14:18

If your question wasn't so convoluted, my answer would be obvious...Twit

 

You name your post...Is it legal?

Then you end it with...Is it legal to do it?

 

So which part of NO   don't you understand? 

Last edit : Wed 6th Aug 2008 14:22

Wayne Santorini



Handicap : 15.4

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 14:25

blimey Davina, have you not taken your afternoon medicine and your medication yet!!!!!!!!!!

David Marshall



Handicap : 9.3

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 14:29

No

 

 

and

 

 

 

No 


David Marshall



Handicap : 9.3

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 14:33

Just to clarify Tim...

 

Rule 14 - 3a   refers

 

In other words  DISQUALIFICATION 


Tim Hawkins



Handicap : 21.5

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 14:43

The title of the post is 'is it illegal' you silly old duffer.

Presumably the ball could be deemed as using a piece of equipment in an unusual manner.  So does this mean that I can't use my putter left handed to chip out from under a bush or use a 3 wood to putt from the edge of the green?

I think I may have a case for using a ball as a legitimate device for alleviating a medical condition - i.e. my useless hand eye co-ordination prevents me from playing golf properly!


David Marshall



Handicap : 9.3

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 14:52

Then that makes your post both ambiguous and convoluted...You soppy tart.....Try making yourself clear and concise, then I'll know what kind of answer you are looking for.

And don't call me a duffer..... I don't do duff shots.

The putter is called a Texas Wedge, for the kind of shot you are referring to. And it is quite legal...So is using the 3 wood to putt....

Perhaps it would be best if you started using the putter off the tee in the first place, no doubt you would get to the green in less shots if you did. You silly old fart.

Last edit : Wed 6th Aug 2008 14:53

Wayne Santorini



Handicap : 15.4

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 15:13

miaowwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww

Tim Hawkins



Handicap : 21.5

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 15:15

And theirin lies my point, oh ancient one.  If everyone turned up with a half a golfball stuck to the inside of their right shoe it couldn't be deemed to be unusual - in much the same way as the first person who used a 3 wood as a putter should have been disqualified until the practice was deemed to be commonplace.

As for medical conditions, my brother and I both suffer from the same swing faults for different reasons - he has one leg an inch shorter than the other and my left collar bone is an inch shorter (and before you start on about us being from Essex and inbreeding it's because of motorcycle accidents) so we could legitimately have built up right shoes to correct conditions - it's just that half a golf ball is cheaper ('cos we could share one!)


Wayne Santorini



Handicap : 15.4

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 15:17

It's like listening to "Hinge & Bracket" when you two get talking

Tim Hawkins



Handicap : 21.5

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 17:14

What if I accidentally trod on a large stone?

Dave Knatt



Handicap : 27.7

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 17:19

I think Tim might have something here - I remember a golfer getting penalised for lying on a towel whilst hitting a shot so I can see that standing on a golf ball could be illegal due to having an extra bit of equipment to help you.

 

But.....if you turned up with a shoe that had a rounded heel, then maybe you could get away with it? 

 


Christopher Watmore



Handicap : 15.9

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 17:33

I think it comes under the ruling of 'Building a Stance' which is why you'd be disqualified.

Jon T



Handicap : 10.9

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 17:43

This is a priceless thread. I wanna report it for a stickie. You pair don't half make me chuckle when you go at it

David Marshall



Handicap : 9.3

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 18:04

Blow standing on a stone Tim...

 

Put your driver on the ground, stand on the head of that, and use your putter off the tee.

 

At least you wouldn't deafen everybody within 500 yards then 


David Marshall



Handicap : 9.3

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 18:05

And another thing....I always wondered why you minced around a golf course.

 

Now we know....You keep your balls in your shoes 


David Ley



Handicap : 7

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 18:43

The sooner we get a Moderator the better.............The decorum on this site is ####ing DIABOLICAL!!!!!

Tim Hawkins



Handicap : 21.5

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Wed 6th Aug 2008 18:56

I've decided to dress like a pirate for the Golfshake Open, no-one will notice then

Wayne Santorini



Handicap : 15.4

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Thu 7th Aug 2008 08:41

Makes a change from playing like a bandit, although they both steal!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Tim Hawkins



Handicap : 21.5

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Thu 7th Aug 2008 09:41

I'll set 'em up Wayne, you hit 'em!


David Marshall



Handicap : 9.3

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Thu 7th Aug 2008 10:17

The blind leading the blind, again

Tim Hawkins



Handicap : 21.5

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Thu 7th Aug 2008 12:39

Just been over the driving range and have found an alternative that seems to work just as well.  Hardly sliced any but now have a tendency to pull them a bit left, think that has more to do with the shoulder width and rubbish aiming.  All seem to be going straight though, even the driver.  Result. 

Mark Bond



Handicap : 14.6

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Thu 7th Aug 2008 13:25

If someone stood on my balls and then proceeded to slice what would happen ?

Wayne Santorini



Handicap : 15.4

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Thu 7th Aug 2008 14:06

You'd have a Martini, shaken not stirred Mr Bond !!!!!!!!!!!

Mark Bond



Handicap : 14.6

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Fri 8th Aug 2008 13:37

Would certainly revoke my licence to thrill.


Post reply :

 Only registered logged in users can post new topics.

Click here to register for free.



Bookmark this page:


Delicious Digg StumbleUpon Facebook reddit
Join for free today