Golf forum



Forum > Technique, Tips & Tuition
out-to-in swing path
John Smith



Handicap : 20

Location :

Posts :
Posted : Sat 28th Jun 2008 20:30

hi, i have always had an out-to-in swing path which used to carry with it a terrible slice. The slice is more controlled as i have gone from average scores of 125 to 95.

Recently, in an effort to swing from the inside, i started bringing my backswing extremely inside so that when i made the over the top movement, my swing was on a good plane.

Should i keep with this ' Jim Furyk in reverse' style swing, or try to come from the inside the conventonal way (proving very difficult)?

Also, any tips on swinging from the inside?



John Pettitt



Handicap : 13.3

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Sat 28th Jun 2008 20:39

Giving yourself a fault, to correct a fault, is not the way to go, John.

The path of the hands on the downswing must be inside the path made by the hands on the backswing.

The most probable cause of your slice , like the majority of high handicappers, is that once the top of the swing is reached, even if on a good plane, the brain takes over by thinking power and the right shoulder is immediately moved forward, thus creating an outside to inside swing path on the way down.

Also it is highly likely that at address you are aligned to the left of target - check your shoulder alignment, this is crucial as the arms are attached to the shoulders and will naturallly swing the way they are facing.

Last edit : Sun 29th Jun 2008 12:39

John Smith



Handicap : 20

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Sun 29th Jun 2008 00:28

john, my shoulders are aligned to the left even though my feet and hips are square to the target line. This feels a very natural position, what is the best way to correct it?

Last edit : Sun 29th Jun 2008 00:29

John Pettitt



Handicap : 13.3

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Sun 29th Jun 2008 10:04

In simple terms, just get that right shoulder back and keep it back, don't hit round it, but under it.

David Wightman



Handicap : 28

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Tue 16th Sep 2008 21:34

I have this problem , my driver stays in the bag unless I'm on the driving range, I play my rounds with irons only, (yes it is a bit embarrasing getting out a 3 iron on a nice wide open par 5).

I have the classic , longer club , worse slice problem. I have been trying to hit inside out on the driving range, but I just can't seem to get a good contact on the ball, most of the time it shoots left along the floor off the heel of the club. It also feels like I can't release my hands and that the club face is wide open.

Do you think its just a case of keep trying and it will come. Just feels so bloody awkward.

Why can't an outside in swing path be the right one, Physics Pah!! 


Hugh Williams



Handicap : 15.7

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Sat 29th Nov 2008 15:01

John - my suggestion is to look to your hands/wrists as the best place to find your solution (I'm convinced this is where most people like us go wrong without realising it). Quite simply, with or without a club in your right hand only, take the action you would use to hammer in a nail and pretend you're hitting a nail at a slight angle into the centre of the ball. Work on this feeling and you will find that you hit more powerful shots getting 70% of your power from your hands/wrists rather than 70% from your shoulders. This should naturally lead to you WANTING to keep your hands/arms closer to the correct inside path (it will feel better to be here than throwing them away from you). You may be surprised that your hands/wrists now release with no conscious effort. You will, at this point, WANT to start hitting the ball between 3pm and 4pm (the right hand side of the ball and slightly closer to to you). Using these swing thoughts, my ball striking has REALLY improved in the last 6 or so rounds and I actually look forward to drilling a 3 or 4 iron rather than block fading/slicing it! The following book is very good for working on these things (although simple): NAILIT with 3skillsgolf: A Revolution in Golf Instruction by Joe Hagan. I would also recommend making swings with left and right hands separately to assist the leearning process. You may find yourself wanting to change your grip. Good luck! Hugh


Michael Bonney



Handicap : 17

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Sat 29th Nov 2008 21:51

I agree wholeheartedly with John when he says that an out to in swing comes from high handicappers looking to put that extra bit of power into the swing ( sort of casting) . I found that with the driver I can pull my right foot away which closes the stance. I then find I can swing confidently at the ball knowing I am coming from the inside. I agree that one should not give oneself a fault to correct a fault, but this minor adjustment is working wonders for me. Good luck I hope you sort it soon.  

Hugh Williams



Handicap : 15.7

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Sat 29th Nov 2008 22:10

John, you may wish to check the following book out too: The Negotiable Golf Swing: How to Improve Your Game Without Picture-Perfect Form. It shows how even all the pro's swing differently at various points in their swing, which areas can be "personal preference" (e.g. swing plane, grip) and which bits must me "standard" (impact). Michael's suggestion is a good one which I have used during a round if things are going wrong! But I would recommend correcting the underlying fault on the range between times. Swing Like A Pro is also an excellent book. as is How to Feel A Real Golf Swing (although this takes longer to make sense and lots of work). All the best, Hugh

John Pettitt



Handicap : 13.3

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Sun 30th Nov 2008 08:58

Michael, what you are doing is not a fault, but the correct way to produce a draw, so you are doing it correctly.

Jonny P



Handicap : 11.5

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Mon 1st Dec 2008 11:26

Huge your advice is terrible mate - you can generate plenty of power without manipulating the wrists. Those big muscles in your shoulder are way more powerful than those little ones in your wrists.

Having a wristy swing for most people will lead to disaster as it's all about timing, if it's off your knackered.

I have said before that if a slicer imagines a laser running in an infinite line 2" above his ball from the target to the back, then all he needs to do is hit the ball without his club breaking the beam.

Couldn't be easier.

Russell Middleton



Handicap : 16

Location :

Posts :
Reply : Mon 1st Dec 2008 18:36

I saw a good tip to prevent you hitting over the top.

All you do is get a sleeve from some golf balls and stand it up 6 inches behind and just outside the target line.

If you swing over the top then you will hit the sleeve before the ball, if you come from the inside you will hit the ball and the sleeve will stay where it is.

Try it, it does work.

Russ



Post reply :

 Only registered logged in users can post new topics.

Click here to register for free.



Bookmark this page:


Delicious Digg StumbleUpon Facebook reddit

Hot Topics

Two Gloves? ...
General golf topics

Seve ...
Chat and Banter

North v South 2009 (North Captain) ...
Any other business?

Powakaddy battery ...
Golf Equipment

North vs South 2009 - thoughts/sugg ...
Organise and Promote your Event

Temp Greens ...
Any other business?

Proud Dad ...
Any other business?

2008 Order of Merit - Review and Re ...
Tour Talk

NEC Golf Show a let down ...
General golf topics

Question: What tees do you play fro ...
Suggestions, requests and feedback