Golf in the Olympics


Forum > Any other business?

Golf in the Olympics

Owen Davies


Handicap : 1

Posted : Tue 31st Jul 2012 09:50

In 2009 it was announced that Golf would be included in the Rio 2016 Games! Is this a good or bad thing? There are good arguments for both sides! Personaly I quite like the idea, but only if the players see it ranking on a similar level to a Major Championship.

http://www.golfshake.com/news/view/4417/Golf_in_the_Olympics_For_or_Against.html

What do you think?

Post reply

John Pettitt


Handicap : 21

Reply : Tue 31st Jul 2012 10:29

The Olympic committee have already introduced sports which have no place in the Olympics, in my opinion. Football, for one.

We have already witnessed a Cycling road race in which 150 of the participants made no effort to win a medal, allowing a cyclist with no outstanding credentials to take a Gold medal.

I also doubt very much if the Golf Professionals would be willing to live in poor accommodation for the duration of the games to win a piece of metal, when they could be somewhere nicer winning money.

Post reply

David Thomas


Handicap : 11.7

Reply : Tue 31st Jul 2012 10:56

Tennis, Golf, Football, Rugby, Cricket etc - big no no - these are all too professional and should not be included in the Olympics

Post reply

Judy Owens


Handicap : 25.1

Reply : Tue 31st Jul 2012 11:26

golf should be included if it was purely amateur. No professionals just amateurs. Of course that would never happen as the money is in the professional game and where there is money there is power!

Post reply

Patrick Bourke


Handicap : 11.3

Reply : Tue 31st Jul 2012 12:56

The olympics profess to have the best in the world...lets have it right, the best that can be bothered. I wish they did have golf on, it'd be more entertaining than watching so called 'sports' like rifle shooting (with a stand to rest your gun on) to hit a moitionless target at 10 metres and the bow and arrow crowd more or less doing the same. I think these two particular sports could join together, the synergy of cowboys and indians would surely be a crowd pleaser. Of course the guns would be paintball bullets and the arrows most definately have rubber suction ends with a 'three deads and you're out' but over the years real ammo could be used and natural selection would ensure both events petered out.

Post reply

Tim Greaves


Handicap : 8.9

Reply : Tue 31st Jul 2012 13:44

Like others have already said, I don't think that golf should be an Olympic sport. I think that sports where the pinnacle of competition is the olympics should only be included. With sports such as golf, tennis, football etc an Olympic gold is not the highest achievable honour. There is not 1 golfer who would swap a major win for olympic gold !

Post reply

Jack Oliver


Handicap : 23.5

Reply : Tue 31st Jul 2012 22:55

Actually John football was in the Olympics from the very beginning, way before the world cup started and long before the game became what it is today.

I'd agree that it doesn't belong these days (and feel the same way about tennis and golf) what with all the ££££ involved in the pro game, but when it was added it was just as amateur as any of the other sports.

Post reply

Robert Haynes


Handicap : 19.3

Reply : Wed 1st Aug 2012 07:14

The idea that the Olympics is an am sport has long gone since sponsorships came about etc. However I do not believe that sport such as golf, football etc where professionals are permitted to play should be included. As for shooting and archery I ask that you try it before banning. Its dam hard.

Post reply

Patrick Bourke


Handicap : 11.3

Reply : Wed 1st Aug 2012 08:50

Sorry foxey, was only having a laugh. I would try it but I'm sure 'no shooting' is one condition of my probation. Seriously though, as you say the Olympics should be non pro only. I think given some of the sports then it is a bit mind boggling why golf isn't there. It's one of the most popular games and would do nothing but good for the whole comp. See you Sun @ Ramsdale.

Post reply

Dan Kavanagh


Handicap : 3.8

Reply : Wed 1st Aug 2012 16:46

no....there are already to many pro sports in the olympics.

The olympics are the ultimate prize for most of the 'lesser known' sports, it is their 'major'.

If they did introduce golf then id like to see a two or three man/woman team format, maybe combined score or points , but not a 140player field with a cut....something abit different and maybe more interesting and fun...

Post reply

Darren Ramowski

[FORUM MODERATOR]
Handicap : 21.6

Reply : Wed 1st Aug 2012 16:49

Dan, exactly! something abit different and maybe more interesting and fun

Nick's written up a post on his views here which is a great article:

http://www.golfshake.com/news/view/4430/Should_Golf_be_an_Olympic_Sport.html

Post reply

Slawomir Kochaj


Handicap : 13.3

Reply : Wed 1st Aug 2012 17:56

Why not but with out profesional. Look for tenis thesame players from wembledon playing now on olimpic . Where is sens????? But if this is ok why profesional boxers not in?

Post reply

Patrick Bourke


Handicap : 11.3

Reply : Thu 2nd Aug 2012 09:40

I hasten to add that I was talking amatuer only, the pros wouldn't turn out a) because of no money and b) why should they put themselves alongside pleb menials that JUST MIGHT give them a run for their money?

Post reply

Dan Kavanagh


Handicap : 3.8

Reply : Thu 2nd Aug 2012 10:54

On the boxing theme......amatuer boxing and pro boxing are in effect two different sports played under different rules, no KO's head guards, length of bout etc..this is why amatuer boxing is in, well that is the reason that it got in. Why football, tennis etc are in I have no idea.

Surpose if onee pro sport is in then why not all in...

Post reply

Connor Jordan


Handicap : 27.6

Reply : Fri 3rd Aug 2012 14:56

thats the thing though, if a boxer wins he decides to go pro, golf and tennis etc should be amateur only at the olympics

Post reply

Dan Kavanagh


Handicap : 3.8

Reply : Fri 3rd Aug 2012 15:37

Connor, i agree that olympics should be amatuer, but its too late now. the precident as been set by letting pros in....

....i dont think pros actually get paid, but 'bonus' is paid by some countries olympic commitees to athletes get podium finishes...

Also i think it can become unfair to allow a sport into olympics that are dominated by only a few different nations, look at the allstar NBA usa team in the basketball..

Post reply

Greg Mendoza


Handicap : 25.5

Reply : Mon 6th Aug 2012 10:26

I'm not sure if golf should be in the Olympics, but would tend to agree that as one of the few sports that has a genuine amateur status, there is no reason why it should not be an amateur comp. Maybe giving a tour card to the gold medalist?

However, for those who think the big names won't attend because of the money (or lack of it), I think you only have to look at the mens singles tennis final yesterday contested by two of the worlds current greatest sportsmen to see that it's more than money. Like the Ryder Cup, this would be an opportunity for tour pro's to move away from the lonely grind that is the European / PGA tours and do something as part of a team with your country's name on the sleeve - I think you'll be surprised by who competes.

Post reply

Owen Davies


Handicap : 1

Reply : Mon 6th Aug 2012 11:32

There is nothing in it on the Poll on the Golfshake Facebook page! 130 votes, 3 undecided. 64 saying it is a bad thing and 63 saying it is a good thing!!

https://www.facebook.com/golfshake

http://glfs.hk/golfshake-facebook

Last edit : Mon 6th Aug 2012 14:02
Post reply

Darren Ramowski

[FORUM MODERATOR]
Handicap : 21.6

Reply : Mon 6th Aug 2012 14:02
Post reply

Terry Woodhouse


Handicap :

Reply : Wed 29th Aug 2012 14:25

I think it should be in - but for the amateurs ONLY Keep it in the spirit of the Olympics

Post reply

Previous Post: Taylormade R5 head covers    |    Next Post: Most forgivving driver??

Post reply :

 Only registered logged in users can post new topics.

Click here to register for free.

 


Golfshake Features

Nikon and Mastercard Priceless Experience

Nikon & Mastercard Offer

Chance to play Open venue
 
2013 Golf GPS

2013 Golf GPS

Thinking of getting a golf GPS?
 
Performance Golf Shoes

Performance Golf Shoes

2013 performance golf shoes
 
Cleveland Wedge Trade in Offer

Cleveland Wedge Offer

Trade in save £25!!
 
Four Course Classic

Four Course Classic

UKs biggest golf challenge